Niti Bhan

Lovingly made by human mind and hands

Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Publications
  • Design Research
  • Contact
Menu

Category: Research

Meta-research for improving design practice

Posted on October 31, 2026November 2, 2026 by Niti Bhan

Ioannidis, J. P. (2018). Meta-research: Why research on research matters. PLoS biology, 16(3), e2005468.

According to John Ioannidis of the Meta-Research Innovation Center at Stanford (METRICS), whatever else that the words meta-research may convey to the reader, this relatively new young discipline is the study of bias (Ioannidis 2018:1/6).  What I find interesting is that Ioannidis (2018) is very clearly and firmly situated within the positivism/positivism (a research paradigm, the oldest worldview on ‘science’ and its method). Thus, unlike my other reflective reviews, this one will intersperse more articles on the topic to round out the authorial stances and viewpoints. While research on research matters indeed (Ioannidis 2018), the how and why it matters will differ according to what, where, with whom, and from which viewpoint (research paradigm/worldview) one approaches the very notion of research as scientific engagement. For instance, in my school of design research, scientific acts (Sato 2000) are undertaken with the aim to improve design performance in the world (Poggenpohl & Sato 2009); and, if a better means to understand and represent our ‘users’ may be necessary to overcome embedded bias in the method or tool or practice implemented to elicit understanding of a people, then it follows that one’s user-centric design practice will inevitably improve with illumination of blindspots. Here,  for this blogpost I do not quibble between user-centric and human-centric although there are strands of design research discourse which do. Here, I am using the best word for clarity of communication to the widest audience, not just within the confines of academic discourse.

McGee, R. G., & Dawson, A. C. (2020). Fake news and fake research: Why meta‐research matters more than ever. Journal of Paediatrics and Child Health, 56(12), 1868-1871.

“Meta-researchers study, analyse and critique the research pathway”(McGee & Dawson 2020:1868). And, because my own meta-research sits outside the dominant research paradigms of the scientific method espoused by McGee & Dawson (2020) I will reverse the order of the words used by the authors’ to describe the elements which meta-researchers focus on, such as how to conduct, how to test, how to communicate, how to verify, and how to reward. That is, meta-research focuses on the most important set of How To questions in the pursuit of systematic knowledge production (“research”). What I discarded from the original sentence structure is the word choice made by McGee & Dawson (2020) such as “reproducibility” with “how to verify” next to it in brackets. These are reflections of the set of assumptions encapsulated by their research paradigm; positivism or postpositivism which underpins ‘the’ scientific method. This is not to imply that research using an interpretivist or constructivist paradigm is not science but that there has been a long and contentious history where qualitative methodologies (originally called naturalistic inquiry by Egon Guba) had to battle for legitimacy, recognition, and respect in the corridors of knowledge production. Thus, my preference for the clarity yet flexibility of the “how to” explanations used by McGee & Dawson (2020) to describe the interests of meta-research, including my own. They are more flexible for application across a range of research paradigms.

Continue reading “Meta-research for improving design practice”

Why user needs in climate services design remain unfulfilled

Posted on October 29, 2026October 28, 2026 by Niti Bhan

Holden et al. (2026) recently published very interesting findings in Nature Climate Action and I find they support the arguments I make in my thesis (albeit from a different angle). They “investigate the relationship between users’ current climate-service use and desired needs for completely new climate services for nature-based solutions in Sub-Saharan Africa, based on 530 interviews” (Holden et al. 2026) of people involved in nature-based projects in Ghana, Kenya, Tanzania, Madagascar and South Africa. For the purpose of this excited blog post, I’ll use the Conversation piece written by 4 members of the large author team to popularize their research. What is most interesting, from the service design point of view, is their conclusion:

Simply asking people what climate information they need is not enough. Scientists, providers, users and local and Indigenous knowledge holders need the time, resources and incentives to develop climate services together. (Holden et al. 2026)

That is, simply eliciting user needs is not enough. Co-creation is required, and, most importantly, climate services must be co-created with multiple knowledge systems if they are to be truly useful to the end-users. Nature-based solutions cannot rely only on modern western science but must find ways to collaborate with the indigenous, local, traditional knowledges of the setting.

More than 80% said existing climate services had limitations. One major problem was that Indigenous and local knowledge forecasting or decision making was not connected to formal climate services. For example, in Turkana, Kenya, traditional seers known as Emuron use Indigenous practices to anticipate severe weather and other climate disasters. Elders also send scouts to assess pasture and water before deciding where livestock should move. But these practices are not connected to formal climate services. (Holden et al. 2026)

I see this as a service design challenge, and one which the dominant knowledge system may not be in a position to fulfill. Here, the missing component of ‘user needs’ is not ‘needs’ per se so much as it is the knowledge of the users themselves which is needed. How might we co-create services with multiple knowledge systems?  It is this challenge I address, as a designer and researcher, in my doctoral thesis, beginning with upfront user research for planning and design of just and equitable co-creation interfaces for such public service projects. From my perspective as a professional design researcher, Holden et al. (2026) conducted valuable user research amongst 530 users of climate services in multi-epistemological settings where local, traditional, and indigenous knowledge systems can be expected. Clearly, to find scholarship which pinpoints the exact challenge I chose to focus on as one which remains unfulfilled is exciting.

Featured image: A photograph of the water supply system in an arid region of Kenya, taken by Niti Bhan in October 2011. 

Advocating inquiry-led planning of projects (Harrison & Whyte 2026)

Posted on October 18, 2026October 27, 2026 by Niti Bhan

Harrison, J., & Whyte, J. (2026). Future-Making in the Front-End of Projects. International Journal of Project Management, 102854. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijproman.2026.102854

Interestingly, Harrison & Whyte’s (2026) conclusions inspired me to conceptualize and set up a class of blogposts which I am calling ‘Reflexive Reviews’ (see categories in the right-hand sidebar). What naturally caught my eye was their advocacy for “for more inquiry-led planning in projects” (p. 5), given the arguments I make in my article-based doctoral thesis and my 20 years of front-end inquiry for informing client projects as well as my own research studies. A reflexive review, thus, becomes a way for me to intersperse my observations from field studies and from client project management experiences with the contents of their essay. Whether the reflexivity of my dialectical engagement with literature on my blog is ‘critical reflexivity’ or not is path dependent on the research selected for such a review. I believe it was Alvesson & Sandberg (2011) who observed that the “critical” in ‘critical reflexivity’ can sometimes overwhelm the “reflexivity” (see pg. 252).

Here, I take the stance of an experienced practitioner in doing more or less that which Harrison & Whyte (2026) advocate for in their discourse of project management. What is interesting is that what I’ve been doing has its roots in the front-end of human-centered design and product development, also called innovation planning or design planning (Owen 1992, 2001; Kumar 2012; Keeley et al. 2013). I will use another quote to help explain where I discern nuanced differences between understandings of inquiry, planning, and the front-end when approached from different disciplines (see Davies, Manning & Söderlund 2018). Emphasis is added to distinguish the two viewpoint they compare.

We suggest that project planning could benefit from complementing early-stage certainty and commitment with more reflexive and inquiry- led practices that allow for iteration, divergence, and adaptation over time. (Harrison & Whyte 2026:5 with emphasis added)

Continue reading “Advocating inquiry-led planning of projects (Harrison & Whyte 2026)”

Playgrounds of the mind

Posted on October 15, 2026October 17, 2026 by Niti Bhan

They say, in the department, that nobody ever reads the synopsis (also called exegesis or kappa) except the examiners. So I followed the standard template assiduously. And failed spectacularly. Oh, I had original contributions to make, my examiners were convinced, but my presentation of my dissertation research was not only not accepted for publication (and hence public defence) but the decision agreed by all was that this was a major revision. Not a minor one. Not a moderate one. Not an outright rejection either. Nope. It was ‘go back and do it all over again’.

So I did.

As I sit here now, less than a week after sending it in again for re-examination, I can only think that this decision was the best thing that ever happened to me in my doctoral journey. A major revision comes with ample time to think, to review, to revise, and to rewrite. The committee offers you 12 months for delivery. I aimed for 3, then aspired to finish in 6 but by the time the myriad little details were all worked out and last minute corrections shoved in, it was almost 7 months before it was ready to go public. I hope my examiners haven’t forgotten me, I’ve been in my cave for so long.

This time I wrote something that wanted to be read. Its a nuanced difference, but I think an important one for me.

I now approached it as the public dissemination of academic scholarship as a doctoral candidate of a university whose birth I remember. Whose reveal party I attended in September 2007; whose prototype I toured in September 2008; and whose research community I joined in September 2019. Yet, interestingly, no matter how often I look back over almost 20 years of involvement, I cannot find any evidence that I could have ever produced anything of this quality and positionality had I begun writing my doctoral thesis any earlier than this time of life.

That is, this is not the dissertation of what is commonly known as “an early career researcher” although technically, according to the formal academic definition, that is exactly what I am at this grand old age of 60. I remember telling someone I’m not “early career” anything at this point. On one hand, as my publications show, I have only a handful of peer reviewed scientific research articles; a popular way to assess the relative “earliness” of a researcher’s career. On the other hand, I have more than 10 commissioned research reports and a track record of funded research projects going back the same 20 years. Its complicated, she said.

For now I will use the status of ‘Independent Researcher’. Its a good enough at this moment in time. I have built reputations, brands, and careers over the past 36 years. Now, I will undergo my own major revision; in no small thanks to the fatal crash of this website.

It opens a new question: What do I want to build next?

This is an absolutely wonderful question. It motivates. It does not inspire. But, what it does is, leave open many possibilities and many searchways for inspiration. In the meantime, I have my blog up and running. And, that, perhaps, is the most important thing of all at transitional times like this.

Here be ‘playgrounds of the mind‘ (with apologies to Larry Niven)…

  • Co-Creation
  • Design
  • Long Read
  • Marginalia
  • Perspective
  • Playground of the mind
  • Reflexive Reviews
  • Research
  • October 2026

Africa blindspot climate change climate services co-creation commentary cultural interface design design exhibition design research epistemological pluralism ILTK indigenous epistemologies indigenous knowledge JDE Jorge Diego Etienne local local knowledge meta-research Mexico Museo Franz Mayer nature-based projects observation plurality project planning research paradigms service design traditional user research UX research

Business Registration

Emerging Futures Lab

Y-Tunnus 2607854-3

Ymmärrys ry

Y-Tunnus 3288926-2

.

Design Research Services

Lorem Ipsum

©2026 Niti Bhan